Left to Right: Frank, Alice, Shelley, Mary, Prudence, Adam
Remus, Sirius, James, Lily, Marlene, Lathe
Peter, Carlotta, Reginald, Clancy, Donna, Luke
***
***
Also, because I'm pretty much a sucker for the Anonymouses =P:
“You’re kind of self-righteous,” said Carlotta.
Lily sighed. “Kind of? As in, it’s kind of my defining characteristic?”
michael seater makes everything better, including the fact that he's peter pettigrew.
ReplyDeletehe makes me want to like peter. but that is bad!
bad bad bad
because peter is reason for everything horrible in this world.
but anyway, your james is the cutest thing i've ever seen.
OMG THIS IS PERFECT!!! haha, I love it! Who is the James guy again?
ReplyDeleteyuck.
ReplyDeletejk.
no seriously, why is ginny in lily's place? cristina capotondi! :(
and why is sookie alice instead of that girl from american dreams you had before?
agree with all except lily, james, and sirius.
I like it :-) super cute!
ReplyDeleteOooh! That is really fantastic!
ReplyDeleteLol, GOD potato, why you hatin?
ReplyDeleteNo, I'm kidding. The Cristina pics didn't mesh as well with the James pic.
@Kelsey, James is Julien Morris.
I disagree with the choices for James and Sirius, but I suppose I'll always agree with everyone's choices for James and Sirius. Also, I preferred Cristiana Capotondi as Lily, but I still love Karen Gillan as well. All in all, very cute. Good job!
ReplyDeleteUh, no! Definitely Karen Gillan. I think Cristiana Capotondi's pictures (I've never seen her act or anything) are either sexy model poses or boring, neither of which scream Lily to me. Not to mention she's, like, 30.
ReplyDeleteLove the Carlotta, love Reg, love Sirius... etc. :D
...and Remus is gorgeous. ;)
ReplyDelete:D
ReplyDeleteI think my favorite out of all of them is Donna. =]
=D
ReplyDeletei was kinda hoping for another excerpt to go along with this.... :]
I SEE BAMBI <3
ReplyDeleteI love this so much!
A++++ Jules.
And I love your James quite a lot.
Seriously, this needs to be printed and framed somewhere.
ReplyDeleteactually, I like Nicole Fox for Lily.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.starpulse.com/news/index.php/2009/11/19/nicole_fox_wins_america_s_next_top_model
she's got the green eyes and bright hair going for her :)
BEN BARNES for Sirius!
Unfortunately for James, I can only imagine a handsomer and taller Daniel Radcliffe.
I love Donna. Exactly how I pictured her.
God, I love your story.
This post made me super hyper! :-D
ReplyDeleteLOL @ Bambi!!
ReplyDelete:O oh no she di'int.
ReplyDeletehope this isn't why lily cries.
but carlotta hostility already <3
BREE YOU HAVE FOUND THE LILY IN MY HEAD.
ReplyDeleteI'M SO HAPPY. THIS HAS BEEN KILLING ME.
<33333
This is awesome! I agree with all of them!
ReplyDeleteUm, I am so sorry but Micheal cannot be Peter. Micheal Seater is my one love, my dear friend. He's one of the few awesome Canadians from Toronto/Brampton area, my hometown, except Micheal Cera and Russell Peters. No, no I refuse!! He can be that guy from HighSchoolMusical, ANYTHING but Micheal Seater!!
ReplyDelete..and I think your James is a cutie!! Really, truly adorable :-))
ahh i love it! but what about joanna garcia as lily... http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_BwhIxvRk96Q/TO-POlQTpLI/AAAAAAAAJRk/1hwscWXl4Zo/s400/priveleged-garcia_l.jpg
ReplyDeleteI want to give Lily a big hug :(
ReplyDeleteI first saw Elena Satine on this very blog and she has replaced any other candidate for Lily in my head. Seriously, I see all these names and I just think 'Why? When there's Elena Satine out there?'
ReplyDeleteAs for Sirius - I never watched Gilmore Girls, so all I know that actor from is Heroes and it's got to be said - what a boring twat! I can never see him as Sirius.
As for Lily Allen for Mary... I don't think she goes together with your Reg that well. Maybe that other one you said (can't remember her name)?
And who's Shelley? She looks too pretty for Shelley, cos she's supposed to be quite plain, no?
Lol, it sounds like I'm dissing your every choice. So - I LOVE your Adam, Donna, Marlene, but most especially your Remus :)
And I love Karen Gillan too! - just not for Lily.
Karen is Ginny. I absolutely adore <33 Karen but not as Lily. The first episode Doctor Who she was in, all I could think was 'Omg, Ginny!'
ReplyDeleteSo... yeah. As for Lily... Idk. All the redheads in the world who are possible contenders for Lily in my head - they're all either not pretty enough or too bitchy looking. Which is why I'm erring on the side of Elena Satine, I guess. Very pretty, but not necessarily bitchy looking. However she doesn't look feisty/cheeky enough. *sigh* So hard.
I have a slight problem in that everyone is too good-looking. Everyone. I feel like I'm looking at The O.C. poster more than Harry Potter.
ReplyDeleteWhat bothers me about the Harry Potter films - they all turned out ridiculously good-looking! Including Rupert Grint! NONE OF THEM were described as good-looking except Hermione once in GoF and then in DH. Ironically, the one person who is described as good-looking is Ginny, and she... well, bless her.
But other than that, I look at people's ideas of characters, and I just go 'Huh? Remus was a model? Peter was skinny? James, who IS supposed to be skinny has a massive six-pack and bulging biceps?'
They're too good looking? Well they are actors! Most young actors are better looking than ordinary people (most, not all). Of course they were all going to be good looking. If she wanted them to look plain then she would have posted Facebook pictures of ordinary people which would not have been creepy at all -___-
ReplyDeleteReg and Marlene aren't very good-looking in that picture.
ReplyDeleteNo one wants to watch ugly people on their TVs, unless it's a reality show where the purpose is to feel superior to the characters.
that version of james is really growing on me! something about the smile...
ReplyDelete& this doesn't look like the cristiana capotondi that you originally posted, jules, but the site claims it's her...and i think its a perfect lily photo (but post-hogwarts)
http://www.zimbio.com/pictures/RGZspheMyM6/Lancia+Hosts+Musa+Diva+Awards/fqk7Su8UgeO/Cristiana+Capotondi
So we come right off the bat with Lily/Carlotta tension. This is gonna be fun
ReplyDeleteThis picture is is exactly how I see lily:
ReplyDeleteChristiana Capotondi- Dalla Vita on Poi photo call
Bitch said what now?! Oh, Carlotta. Hasn't she learned yet that Lily will PWN her, verbally, every time she tries to start something?
ReplyDelete@11:11 yup. equal parts beautiful and nice.
ReplyDeletei don't find karen gillan beautiful enough to believe guys like james (and luke) would throw themselves at her.
quirky, cute, and fun maybe, but not beautiful, imo.
lol, have you seen girl's legs?!?
ReplyDeleteSeems like I'm the only one there who still hasn't seen Doctor Who.She's cute and has those endless leg which I would like to have.Zoe as Donna is also a good choice and your James is so adorable.Your James and Lily actually look good together.You can take your time if you want,I doubt moste people would be able to write good quality chapter this long in only a week.
ReplyDeleteI actually like Karen Gillan as Lily but I also like Elena Satine so I don't really know what to think.Your James is so fucking adorable,which actor did you chose?I also love your choice with Donna but I have to disagree with Shelley and Sirius.The rest are okay and seem to fit the characters well.I hope you'll update soon,but no pressure.
ReplyDeleteAwesome :)
ReplyDeletejust googled the legs.
ReplyDeletethose + hogwarts skirts...
lol, makes more sense now.
This picture is now my desktop background. Haha, how obsessive-fan of me, right? Though it was a bit of a debate, because this is what it was replacing:
ReplyDeletehttp://thegreatgeekmanual.com/images/humor/motivational/june/motivational-poster-hufflepuff-dynamos.jpg
@ chubbypotato: i just googled the legs
ReplyDeletetoo. it really does make more sense! lol
i love karen gillan as lily but....
ReplyDeletehttp://images4.fanpop.com/image/photos/18600000/Karen-Gillan-karen-gillan-18633723-500-435.jpg
turns out she's a hufflepuff. *sigh
Maybe she could find someone else?
ReplyDelete...
Someone had to do it.
chubby you're complaining about Karen not being pretty enough? She's absolutely gorgeous! I think she makes a perfect Lily! (except for the super short skirts - I can't imagine LaT Lily dressing like that). But my only problem is I can't imagine her without the scottish accent :)
ReplyDeleteBut Cristiana Capotondi... am I the only person who doesn't she's pretty? Ok I guess, but definitely not enough to have loads of guys throwing themselves at her. I'm more happy with Elena Satine and Karen (who are both gorgeous) as Lily than Christina Capotondi who I honestly dont think is pretty at all.
Seriously, who is your Adam? Cos he's awesome...just saying. Plus James is Perfect...
ReplyDeleteOn the Lily debate, I <3 Karen Gillan... :)
Karen Gillan or Elena Satine. Not Cristina Capotondi... I don't want to sound bitchy, but I genuinely don't think her very pretty. Definitely nowhere near as pretty as Karen Gillan or Elena Satine. However, Elena Satine is too... glamourous and sophisticated looking, not too mention she looks too innocent, and we know that Lily was a bit cheeky and smart-mouthed... so I'm happy going with Karen, cos she seems to have it all :)
ReplyDeleteAdam = Zach Gilford.
ReplyDeletei kind of imagine leven ramblin as lily, http://yfrog.com/b98viqj
ReplyDeletebut just with some adjustments.
How about Allie Trimm as Clancy Goshawk? She's got the cutest girl-next-door look, and that's how I imagine her.
ReplyDeleteAnd Dana Davis (a younger Dana Davis, obviously) as Donna Shacklebolt? http://www.popentertainment.com/DanaDavisNUP_109188_0232.jpg
ReplyDeleteAnd BEN BARNES = PERFECT SIRIUS.
ReplyDelete